Drug Pipeline

Older adults with early dementia keep guns loaded for protection

Older adults with early dementia keep guns loaded for protection

A retired health administrator, 72, kept two firearms within arm’s reach every night—a loaded .45-caliber pistol in a nightstand drawer and an unloaded shotgun propped by his bed, with shells atop the nightstand. Diagnosed with mild cognitive impairment and depression, he viewed the guns as essential protection.

Laura Prater, a firearms researcher at Ohio State, documented his case during a study on gun safety for older adults. “He kept it loaded in his nightstand drawer,” she said of the pistol. The shotgun, unloaded but with shells nearby, was positioned by his bed. “He saw them as a practical tool for protecting himself, because he lived alone,” Prater noted. To her, the arrangement was alarming—but not uncommon.

Researchers estimate that at least a third of people with dementia have access to firearms. Convincing them to surrender those weapons proves difficult because guns often define their identity. Owners cite protection as a key reason for having firearms, so “you’re taking away their identity as a protector, removing a part of who they are,” said Kelsey Conrick, a researcher at the Center for Firearm Injury Prevention at the University of Washington.

Why Gun Storage Matters Most

A harm-reduction approach, discussing risks, promoting secure storage, and offering free locking devices, has proven more effective than outright confiscation. More than 90% of these deaths were suicides, making storage the most critical intervention.

Researchers now focus on older adults with early cognitive decline; those who haven’t been diagnosed with dementia but show worsening confusion or memory loss. A survey across seven states found that one-third of people 65 and older with subjective cognitive decline reported owning a gun, and a quarter stored them unsafely. That rate of insecure storage was higher than among those with normal cognition, though the difference wasn’t statistically significant.

“We worry about these people getting confused and having quick, unfettered access to a firearm,” Conrick said. The risks include unintentional discharges, mistaken shootings of family members, or suicide attempts during moments of impaired judgment.

Older gun owners often dismiss data showing that firearms in the home increase suicide and accident risks. “Still, numbers don’t always motivate people’s decisions when they’re related to fear or risk,” said Marian Betz, an emergency physician and director of the Firearm Injury Prevention Initiative at the University of Colorado Anschutz. A 2011 meta-analysis found no credible evidence that guns deter crime or reduce injuries from intrusions, yet many owners cling to them for perceived safety.

Caregivers’ Silent Struggle and Solutions

Caregivers face their own challenges. A study led by Betz found that only about 5% of caregivers for people with dementia said a healthcare professional had ever discussed firearm safety with them. Families may avoid confronting older relatives about gun storage due to fear of conflict, or because they assume disclosure could lead to confiscation. In reality, only 22 states and Washington, D.C., have extreme risk protection order laws that allow temporary firearm restrictions, and even then, depression or dementia alone don’t automatically trigger such measures.

Chris Knoepke, a health services researcher, found that many caregivers had witnessed reckless behavior, near misses, accidental discharges, but hesitated to intervene.

Public health experts are developing tools to address these gaps. Prater’s team is creating videos to guide clinicians through safe storage discussions. Conrick’s Pathways 2 Safety program has distributed over a thousand locking devices since March. At the University of Colorado, Betz’s Safety in Dementia online tool helps caregivers prepare for firearm-related decisions, while the Firearm Life Plan, used by nearly 16,000 people since 2022, allows owners to document future storage plans.

Emerging Strategies to Address Firearm Risks in Cognitive Decline

Experts are exploring ways to integrate firearm safety measures into routine medical care for older adults showing early signs of cognitive decline. A recent proposal suggests including discussions about gun storage and access during annual Medicare wellness visits, which reach about 60% of beneficiaries. This approach aims to normalize safety conversations within existing healthcare frameworks, avoiding politically charged debates.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *